Kitap hakkında
Ibn Al-Humām’s Views On Talfīq: An Analytical Study seeks to determine what Ibn al-Humām actually meant by the enigmatic phrases in his books—phrases that have divided Ḥanafī scholars for centuries and that some now invoke to justify talfīq as a legitimate method of legal reasoning. Superficial and unilateral approaches lacking grounding in the well-established edifice of uṣūl al-fiqh have sparked new controversies among Muslims—talfīq being one of the most prominent phenomena in this regard today. Alongside established methods of legal reasoning such as istiḥsān and takhrīj, some contemporary scholars have come to regard talfīq—combining the jurisprudential views of different scholars—as a legitimate method within the Ḥanafī mad̲h̲hab. At the heart of this debate lie the ambiguous statements found in Ibn al-Humām's al-Taḥrīr and Fatḥ al-Qadīr, which appear to indicate the permissibility of tatabbu‘ al-ruk̲h̲aṣ and the non-prohibition of talfīq. While Qāsim bin Quṭlūbughā—who studied directly under Ibn al-Humām—repeatedly held that talfīq is impermissible based on these very statements, scholars such as Ibn Nujaym al-Miṣrī and Mullā Farrūkh cited the same statements as evidence for its permissibility. Drawing on the commentaries, glosses, and interpretive literature written on these phrases, this book examines the distinction between acceptable and unacceptable forms of talfīq and investigates the underlying causes of disagreement among uṣūlī scholars on this matter.